Krolik Marketing

Why does ChatGPT recommend a competitor instead of my business?

Because ChatGPT's answers change each time, and most don't name any one business. In one study by a tool company, ChatGPT named a business the company was tracking in about 1 search in 3. The one cause OpenAI documents that you can fix: blocking its search robot.

An AI assistant's spotlight falls on a competitor's shop while your shop sits under a faint dashed beam.

What you can do today

Run a fair test before you worry. Write up to three questions a customer would ask, with your town in them. Ask each one in a new chat, three times. Count how many of the nine answers name you: "named in X of 9." More asks give a steadier count.

Then read the result:

  • You appear sometimes. That is normal.
  • You never appear. Check whether your site blocks OAI-SearchBot, OpenAI's search robot (the program that reads your website for ChatGPT), and check your business listings.
  • A wrong fact appears, such as old hours. Correct it where it comes from. Cheers, a tool company, says "A verified wrong fact can be corrected without waiting for repeated answers."

Also claim your ChatGPT business profile if OpenAI lets you. To tell whether customers came from ChatGPT, see this page.

Not being named is normal

Everything below that isn't from OpenAI or Google comes from companies that sell tracking tools. It shows patterns, not causes.

In BrightLocal's study of about 200,000 local searches, ChatGPT named a business the company was tracking in 33% of searches. BrightLocal sells the tracker it used. So a business that is not named in most ChatGPT searches is the normal case, not a sign that something is broken.

Share of local searches that named a tracked business: Google Maps 66%, AI Overviews 38%, ChatGPT 33%, AI Mode 32%.

The names move

Answers change each time you ask. The competitor you saw may not be named next time, and you may be named on days you didn't check. Here is why.

Possible reasons, by strength of evidence

Documented by OpenAI

  • Your robots.txt (a small file on your site that tells robots what they may read) blocks OAI-SearchBot. OpenAI: "Sites that are opted out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers." A firewall or a hosting service in front of your site can block it as well.
  • ChatGPT "ranks search results using multiple factors". "Placement is not guaranteed." OpenAI does not list the factors.
  • Claiming a ChatGPT profile "doesn't guarantee increased visibility", and "Advertising doesn't influence ChatGPT's independent answers." A competitor who claimed one has no documented edge.

Measured by tool companies, correlation only

  • Directories. Most ChatGPT answers that cite anything cite a directory or review site, so check your listings.

Not known: what makes ChatGPT pick one local business over another. No source says.

For auto repair and body shops

I found no data for body shops, and none on why one auto repair shop gets named over another.

Based on public documentation: BrightLocal; Cheers; OpenAI documentation; OpenAI help.

All posts