
This is not legal advice; rules differ by state and change. I quote regulators and statutes here and do not interpret them. I read every text quoted below on November 16, 2026. I did not check any state beyond the four below, and I have not run this question through ChatGPT.
What you can do today
- Open your state insurance department's page on choosing a repair shop. Copy its sentence word for word, copy the web address, and write down the date you read it.
- Put that sentence on your site under a heading in the customer's own words: "Do I have to use my insurance company's body shop?" Use the wording below.
- Add your real answers on towing, rental cars and repair time. Don't promise what an insurer will pay.
- Don't criticize insurers' shops.
- Ask ChatGPT the question three times, each in a new chat, naming your state. Open the list of websites it shows and compare it with your regulator's page.
Wording you can adapt
Do I have to use my insurance company's body shop?[Your state's regulator] says: "[exact sentence from its page]." Source: [agency name], [web address], read [date].You can ask us for an estimate whatever shop your insurer suggests. This is general information, not legal advice. Rules differ by state and change. Check your policy and ask your insurer.
Quote only your own state's regulator. If its page has no such sentence, leave the quote out rather than write one yourself.
Add a line about direct repair programs only if it is true for your shop and your agreement allows it.
What four regulators say
California. The Department of Insurance: "Under California Insurance Code §758.5 an insurance company cannot require that an automobile be repaired at a specific repair shop. However, an insurance company can recommend that an automobile be repaired at a specific repair shop under the following conditions outlined by law:" Its page then lists those conditions.
The statute, Insurance Code §758.5(a): "No insurer shall require that an automobile be repaired at a specific automotive repair dealer, as defined in Section 9880.1 of the Business and Professions Code." And §758.5(b)(1): "No insurer shall suggest or recommend that an automobile be repaired at a specific automotive repair dealer unless either of the following applies: (A) A referral is expressly requested by the claimant. (B) The claimant has been informed in writing of the right to select the automotive repair dealer."
The Department's Consumer Bill of Rights: "AN INSURANCE COMPANY SHALL NOT REQUIRE THE REPAIRS TO BE DONE AT A SPECIFIC AUTO BODY REPAIR SHOP."
Montana. The Commissioner of Securities and Insurance, in an August 21, 2024 advisory memorandum: "In Montana, a consumer has the sole discretion to choose where the consumer's vehicle will be repaired. §33-18-224(4). This means an insurance company may not require that a claimant use a particular auto repair shop or location for an estimate or repair."
Rhode Island. The Department of Business Regulation, Industry Alert 2025-2: "'steering' is prohibited in accordance with RI Gen. Laws 27-29-4(15)-(16)". The alert quotes the statute, which lists among "unfair methods of competition and unfair and deceptive acts or practices in the business of insurance": "(15) Requiring that repairs be made to an automobile at a specified auto body repair shop or interfering with the insured's or claimant's free choice of repair facility."
Rhode Island's rule for motor vehicle damage appraisers, 230-RICR-20-50-3, section 3.7(E)(1), says the appraisal "shall contain" a "notice in boldface type, reading as follows": "PURSUANT TO RHODE ISLAND LAW, THE CONSUMER HAS THE RIGHT TO CHOOSE THE REPAIR FACILITY TO COMPLETE REPAIRS TO A MOTOR VEHICLE; AND AN INSURANCE COMPANY MAY NOT INTERFERE WITH THE CONSUMER'S CHOICE OF REPAIRER."
Oregon. The Division of Financial Regulation: "No. Oregon law prohibits an insurer from requiring you to use a certain repair shop."
The statute, ORS (Oregon Revised Statutes) 746.280(1): "An insurer may not require that a particular person make the repairs to the insured's motor vehicle as a condition for recovery by the insured under a motor vehicle liability insurance policy."
ORS 746.285: "A person operating a motor vehicle body and frame repair shop shall display in a conspicuous place in the shop a sign in bold face type in letters at least two inches high reading substantially as follows:" "PURSUANT TO OREGON INSURANCE LAW, AN INSURANCE COMPANY MAY NOT REQUIRE THAT REPAIRS BE MADE TO A MOTOR VEHICLE BY A PARTICULAR PERSON OR REPAIR SHOP."
An insurance-industry group. Triple-I is not a regulator. Its FAQ says: "Consumers have the right to go to the auto shop of their choice and get their own repair estimate." It also says shops in insurers' direct repair programs, networks of shops an insurer approves, are "carefully vetted by insurers".
Based on public documentation: California Department of Insurance; Montana Commissioner of Securities and Insurance; Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation; Oregon Revised Statutes chapter 746; Oregon Division of Financial Regulation; California Insurance Code section 758.5.
- California Department of Insurance: So You've Had an Accident, What's Next? (cites Insurance Code section 758.5), read 2026-11-16
- California Department of Insurance: Auto Body Repair Consumer Bill of Rights
- Montana Commissioner of Securities and Insurance, 2024-08-21: Advisory Memorandum (section 33-18-224, MCA)
- Rhode Island Department of Business Regulation, 2025-04-18: Industry Alert 2025-2
- Oregon Revised Statutes chapter 746, 2025 edition (sections 746.280 and 746.285)
- Oregon Division of Financial Regulation: Repair shops after an accident
- California Insurance Code section 758.5 (leginfo.legislature.ca.gov)
- Montana Code Annotated 2025, section 33-18-224
- Rhode Island General Laws section 27-29-4
- Rhode Island 230-RICR-20-50-3, Motor Vehicle Damage Appraisers
- Triple-I: FAQs about direct repair programs
