
What you can do today
- Write up to three questions a customer would ask, with your town in them. Ask each one in a new chat, three times. Write down every business named.
- Open each one's Google page. Note its review count, star rating and newest review date. Find the lowest review count and the middle one, and compare yours. This is my method, adapted from Glowsearch, which advises looking at "the range of the businesses that already get named in your trade and city."
- Ask each happy customer for a review when the job is done, and send the direct link to your review page. This is my advice. No study shows it moves ChatGPT.
The numbers in circulation
Apart from OpenAI and the academic paper, everything below comes from companies that sell tools or marketing. It shows patterns, not causes.
REACHRIGHT, a church marketing agency, says "somewhere between 30 and 75 reviews." It bases that on "our church clients," shows no data, and writes on the same page: "There's no number Google or ChatGPT has publicly confirmed."
PushLeads, an agency, says "a minimum of 150 reviews per location" and a 4.3-star floor for ChatGPT. I found no study named for either figure.
What Glowsearch measured
Glowsearch, a tool company, asked customer-style questions about 2,035 businesses in September 2026. For ChatGPT alone, the share named:
- under 20 reviews: 1%
- 20 to 49: 14%
- 100 to 249: 23%
- 1,000 or more: 30%
Glowsearch calls this "a correlation, not proof that reviews cause mentions."
For auto repair, 17% of 546 shops in Charlotte and Nashville were named by an AI assistant. The median shop named (the middle one) had 198 reviews. The median shop not named had 95.
What an academic audit found
A research paper posted online before peer review checked 4,776 cafes, restaurants and bars in two Bali markets against answers from ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity.
More reviews went with being named. Star rating did not. That is not the US and not your trade.
Whose reviews does ChatGPT show?
BrightLocal, a vendor, counted what ChatGPT and Google's two AI features pointed to. It says Google Business Profile is "hardly used by ChatGPT" and that all three rely on Yelp. I found no source that settles whose reviews ChatGPT shows. So collect reviews where your customers are, not only on Google. Yelp is one place.
A BrightLocal survey of US adults found 97% of AI users sometimes double-check AI recommendations against real reviews. Your reviews get read after the answer.
What nobody has measured
OpenAI's business page gives no review count and says claiming "doesn't guarantee increased visibility." I found no number for body shops or churches. The church figure above is one agency's say-so.
Based on public documentation: Glowsearch; arXiv 2608.07069; REACHRIGHT; PushLeads; BrightLocal; OpenAI help.
- Glowsearch, updated 2026-10-22: Do Google reviews get you recommended by ChatGPT? (a vendor study)
- arXiv 2608.07069, 2026-08-07: Invisible to the Machine (a preprint)
- REACHRIGHT, 2026-04-08: AI SEO for Churches (a church marketing agency)
- PushLeads, 2026-08-24: Local contractors with fewer than 150 reviews (an agency)
- BrightLocal, 2026-09-16: What 200k local AI searches tell us (a vendor study)
- BrightLocal, 2026-03-10: Nearly half of consumers are asking AI for business recommendations (a vendor survey)
- OpenAI help: Setting up your business on ChatGPT
