Krolik Marketing

Does your Google listing match your website? We checked 20 businesses

Not always. I compared Google's phone number and hours with the business's own website for 20 shops and churches. 7 disagreed on the phone or the hours, 5 of them clearly. It is a small sample, and I could not tell which side was right. Check yours in five minutes.

A phone listing and a website showing different clock times, joined by a not-equal sign

What I found

7 of the 20 disagreed on a phone number or on hours. 5 of those 7 are clear. The other 2 are judgment calls, where reasonable people could read the two pages differently. 9 matched on everything I could see. The other 4 had only gaps, such as hours that show up only in a small add-on box on the page, and no contradiction. None of the 20 had a different address.

I won't name anyone, and I can't tell who is right. Here are the five clear ones.

  • An auto shop in Ohio, Saturday. Google says "Saturday: 9:00 AM – 3:00 PM." The website footer says "Monday - Saturday 09.00 - 18.00." Weekdays and Sunday agree. Saturday closes three hours apart. The shop's Contact page is also an unedited template from another company, with a Los Angeles address and fake 555 phone numbers. Its real details are only on the home page.
  • Two auto shops in North Carolina, phone. In both, the number on Google is a completely different number from the one on the website. The Google number appears nowhere on the home or about page.
  • A church office in Ohio, Friday. Google says "Friday: 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM." The site's footer lists office hours "Friday 8:00 a.m. - 2:00 p.m."
  • A church in California, Sunday and Saturday. Google says "Sunday: 9:00 AM – 12:30 PM" and lists "Saturday: 5:30 – 7:30 PM." The site lists Sunday services at 8:30, 10 and 11:45 and mentions no Saturday service.

The two judgment calls: a Virginia body shop where Google says "Saturday: Closed" and the site says "By Appointment Only", and an Ohio church where Google shows a Sunday evening block the site never lists as a service.

Check yours in five minutes

Do it on your phone.

  1. Open Google Maps. Search your business name and town and open your listing. That is your Google Business Profile, the free listing Google shows for you.
  2. Write down the phone, the address and the hours. Open your listing's hours and read every day, not just today's.
  3. Open your website. Look at the home page, the contact page and the footer, the strip at the very bottom of each page.
  4. Compare phone, address and hours day by day. Saturday, Sunday and the Friday close are where I found the hours gaps.
  5. Church? Compare service times too. Google may show one block of hours where your site lists several services.
  6. Compare your own pages with each other. A contact page can be stale while the home page is right.

Any difference means you have a decision to make: which one is true.

Why it matters

I did not test what ChatGPT says about these 20. But ChatGPT searches, then writes. If a page it reads is old, the answer is old. OpenAI says it "may share your location with trusted third-party providers that help provide more local information, such as nearby business listings or weather reports." On its business page it adds: "ChatGPT may also use other sources when answering questions about your business."

So an assistant can quote your Google listing, your website, or another listing, and I can't say which.

One study, a preprint (posted before other researchers have reviewed it), tested four AI tools on cafes, restaurants and bars in two markets in Bali. They recommended permanently closed venues 93 times. The author writes that "staleness, not hallucination, is the practical failure mode." Put plainly, old information is what goes wrong, not made-up information. That is not the US and not your trade.

What to fix and where

Pick the true phone and hours, then set them everywhere the same day.

How I picked the 20

On 2026-11-16 I searched Google for auto repair shops and body shops in seven cities, and for churches in four of them. I picked the cities myself. For each search I took the first one or two results, in the order Google gave them, that passed my filters. It is not a random draw. I skipped 24 national chain brands by name, businesses with no website, and ones Google marks as not operating. Some multi-location businesses stayed in.

That left 20: 13 shops and 7 churches. For each one I compared what Google shows (phone, address, hours) with what the business's own website says.

What I could not tell

  • Which side is right. Either may be right, or both old. I did not call anyone.
  • How common this is. 20 businesses, 7 cities, drawn in Google's order, not at random. Treat 7 of 20 as what happened here, not a national rate.
  • Church hours. Google's church hours mix office hours and service windows, so "9:00 to 12:30" against "8:30, 10, 11:45" compares unlike things.
  • Hidden content. Some sites keep hours in widgets or images that I did not read.
  • What ChatGPT says. I did not ask it about these 20.

If you want me to look at yours, request my free 30-minute consultation.

All posts